Diagnostic value of ultrasound-guided fine-needle aspiration cytology in the pathological natures of thyroid nodules: A retrospective study

INTRODUCTION

Thyroid nodules are a commonly observed condition in clinical practice with a complex etiology and can be classified as benign or malignant.^[1] Related research results show that the incidence of malignant nodules in patients with thyroid nodules is approximately 5.6–79.8%.^[2] Compared with patients with benign nodules, patients with malignant thyroid nodules have more serious conditions, and their physical and mental health and quality of life are affected,^[3-6] so timely identification of the pathological natures of thyroid nodules is vital.

The puncture technique was first used in the pathological examination of tumors in 1930 and was adopted in the cutting biopsy of thyroid diseases in the 1950s and 1960s. However, traditional coarse needle biopsy can lead to complications or metastasis of tumor cells along the needle tract, limiting its clinical application.^[7-9] Fine-needle aspiration biopsy (FNAB) is a newer technique that offers minimal injury, reduced pain, and ease of operation. FNAB effectively mitigates the complications and metastasis risks associated with coarse needle biopsy, thus reducing the need for unnecessary surgeries. Consequently, it has gradually become the biopsy technique recommended by clinical guidelines.^[10-12] Hence, higher requirements are placed on the puncture path and site accuracy because of the limited tissue dose obtained by fine-needle aspiration.

With the continuous improvement of modern medical technology and ultrasound equipment, ultrasound technology has also been used in thyroid nodule examination, which shows an increasing trend in the detection rate of nodules.^[13-15] Ultrasound-guided fine-needle aspiration cytology (USFNAC) is a minimally invasive technique that effectively diagnoses the nature of thyroid nodules. Unfortunately, clinical reports on the diagnostic value of US-FNAC in determining the nature of thyroid nodules are scarce, and the relationship between the diagnostic efficacy of US-FNAC and nodular diameter has not been established. In this study, the result of post-operative pathological examination was the gold standard for analyzing the value of US-FNAC in diagnosing benign and malignant thyroid nodules and exploring its application effect in nodules of different sizes. This study aims to provide an effective reference for improving the accuracy of clinical diagnosis of nodular natures, determining treatment options, and evaluating prognosis.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Examination and evaluation methods

Surgical pathological examination and evaluation

During the resection of thyroid nodules, all patients underwent resection of lesion nodules under general anesthesia, and a rapid pathological examination of diseased thyroid tissues was carried out. The collected specimens were transferred to the pathology department for assessment by two experienced pathologists at the level of attending physician or above. Consultation was necessary to obtain a unified diagnostic result if different opinions existed.

Typical cancer cells in the specimens were assessed as malignant, and non-typical cancer cells were assessed as benign.

Ultrasound examination and evaluation

The color ultrasound diagnosis equipment (model: Philips EPQ5) with L12–5 probe was selected for ultrasound examination, and the probe frequency was 5–12 MHz. The patient was guided to adopt a supine position, and the pillow was placed behind the patient’s neck to tilt the head backward. After fully exposing the neck skin, ultrasound detected the bilateral thyroid lobes and isthmus and observed nodular location, size, number, morphological characteristics, blood flow, internal echo, and calcification situations.

According to the American Thyroid Association (ATA) guidelines, the ultrasound examination results could be divided into five types.^[16]

Benign

Simple cystic nodules (no solid component).

Super-low suspected malignancy

Spongiform or partially cystic nodules without any of the ultrasound features described in low, moderate, or high suspected pattern.

Low suspected malignancy

Solid nodules with equal or high echo or partially cystic nodules with eccentric solidity. Moderate suspected malignancy

Solid nodules with low echo and smooth margins.

High suspected malignancy

Solid nodules (components) with a low echo of a partially cystic nodule with one or more of the characteristics including irregular edges (infiltrative, microlobulated), microcalcification, longer than wide shape, edge calcification combined with small prominent soft tissue component, and the evidence of extrathyroid extension.

US-FNAC examination and evaluation

According to the results of clinical and ultrasound examinations, the most suspected thyroid nodule was examined through US-FNAC. After disinfection and towel treatment, 2% lidocaine (NMPA approval no.: H37022114; specification: 5 mL: 0.1 g, manufacturer: Shandong Hualu Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd.; origin: Liaocheng, China) at a dose of 50–300 mg was used for local infiltration anesthesia. A 22 G fine needle was selected to puncture the corresponding suspected nodules under ultrasound guidance [Figure 1]. The multi-directional puncture should reach the nodular internals to obtain contents as much as possible. Negative pressure suction was reasonably adopted if the tissue was difficult to extract. If the aspirate contained more blood, the remaining blood was aspirated completely from various directions using a syringe after slightly shaking the glass slide, and then, the suction operations were performed three times, subsequently obtaining specimens. The syringe was withdrawn, the needlepoint was pressed with gauze, and the specimens were placed in the slide, and the slide method was used for examination. Two experienced pathologists (attending physician or above) evaluated the results. When there were different opinions, consultation was needed, and the final diagnosis results were obtained after the unification of opinions.

Close

Figure 1:

Ultrasound-guided puncture images in ultrasound-guided fine-needle aspiration cytology. (a) A low-echo nodule puncture was observed in the right lobe of the thyroid, and (b-d) was displayed in the left lobe of the thyroid.

Export to PPT

According to US-FNAC results, patients could be divided into the following six types.^[17]

1. Patients with non-diagnostic or unsatisfactory specimen results were classified as type I

2. Patients with benign lesions were classified as type II

3. Patients showing atypical cellular lesions with unclear diagnostic significance were classified as type III

4. Patients with suspected or existing follicular tumors belonged to type IV

5. Patients with suspected malignant tumors were classified as type V

6. Patients with definitely diagnosed malignant tumors were classified as type VI.

RESULTS

Baseline data

This study selected a cohort of 116 patients, of which 98 met the inclusion criteria [Figure 2]. Of these, 53 were female (54.08%) and 45 were male (45.92%), with an average age of 53.46 ± 6.62 years (ranging from 32–76 years).

Close

Figure 2:

Inclusion process of patients.

Export to PPT

US-FNAC RESULTS

The US-FNAC results of 98 thyroid nodules showed 9 (9.18%) benign nodules, 84 (85.72%) malignant nodules, and 5 (5.10%) uncertain pathological natures, as shown in Table 4 and Figure 3.

Close

Figure 3:

Cytopathology in patients with thyroid nodules by ultrasound-guided fine-needle aspiration cytology. (a) Hashimoto’s thyroiditis. Lymphadenia, formation of lymphoid follicles, and acidophilic degeneration of follicular epithelium among thyroid follicles were observed (100 µm). (b) Atypical fo llicular adenoma. Rich neoplastic cells, inconspicuous follicular structure in some areas, and mild heterogenic cells were observed (100 µm). (c) Onco1cytoma. The eosinophilic infiltration of thyroid cells, consistent nuclear size, obscure heteromorphism, and complete fibrous capsule around thyroid follicles were observed, and no capsule and vascular invasion were observed (100 µm). (d) Subacute thyroiditis. Destroyed thyroid follicles and overflowed colloids, the infiltration of fibroblast hyperplasia, lymphocytes, plasma cells, neutrophils, and eosinophils, and the reaction of histiocytes and multinucleated giant cells were observed (200 µm). (e) Papillary thyroid carcinoma. Papillary structure and gravel-like calcification could be found (100 µm). (f) Medullary thyroid carcinoma. The cells were arranged in follicular, nested, and trabecular ways. The cytoplasm was bicolorophilic, the nucleus was round or oval, and the chromatin was coarse (200 µm). (3a-f: Hematoxylin and eosin)

Export to PPT

Diagnostic efficacy of US-FNAC for the pathological natures of thyroid nodules

Because the benign and malignant natures of nodules in type I and type III could not be determined, 93 cases were included after excluding nodules in type I and III. The result of the post-operative pathological examination was used as the gold standard for ROC analysis, showing that the AUC, sensitivity, specificity, and 95% confidence interval of US-FNAC were 0.894, 98.80%, 80.00%, and 0.745–1.000, respectively, as shown in Table 5 and Figure 4.

Table 5: Diagnostic efficacy of US-FNAC for the pathological natures of thyroid nodules.

	Benign	Malignant	AUC	Sensitivity (%)	Specificity (%)	95% CI
US-FNAC (n=93)
Benign	8	1	0.894	98.80	80.00	0.745~1.000
Malignant	2	82

US-FNAC: Ultrasound-guided fine-needle aspiration cytology, CI: Confidence interval, AUC: Area under the curve

Close

Figure 4:

Receiver operator characteristic curve of ultrasound-guided fine-needle aspiration cytology diagnosis. (US-FNAC: Ultrasound-guided fine-needle aspiration cytology)

Export to PPT

Diagnostic efficacy of US-FNAC for pathological natures of thyroid nodules with different diameters

According to the median and quartile of nodular diameters, i.e., 1.90 (1.60, 2.30) cm, 93 patients were divided into groups Q1 (≤1.6 cm), Q2 (1.7–1.9 cm), Q3 (2.0–2.3 cm), and Q4 (>2.3 cm). The results of ROC analysis showed that the AUCs of US-FNAC in the above groups were 0.978, 1.000, 0.977,0.971. The AUCs of Q1 group, Q2 group, Q3 group and Q4 group were all > 0.9, and US-FNAC had high diagnostic efficiency for the pathological properties of thyroid nodules with different diameters, as shown in Table 6 and Figure 5.

Table 6: Diagnostic efficacy of US-FNAC for pathological natures of thyroid nodules with different diameters.

Groups	Surgical pathological examination results		AUC	Sensitivity (%)	Specificity (%)	95% CI
	Benign	Malignant
Group Q1 (n=24)
Benign	1	1	0.978	95.70	100.00	0.914-1.000
Malignant	0	22
Group Q2 (n=26)
Benign	3	0	1.000	100.00	100.00	0.000 –1.000
Malignant	0	23
Group Q3 (n=24)
Benign	2	0	0.977	100.00	66.70	0.818-1.000
Malignant	1	21
Group Q4 (n=19)
Benign	2	0	0.971	100.00	66.7	0.774-1.000
Malignant	1	16

US-FNAC: Ultrasound-guided fine-needle aspiration cytology, AUC: Area under the curve, CI: Confidence interval, 93 patients were divided into groups Q1 (≤1.6 cm), Q2 (1.7–1.9 cm), Q3 (2.0–2.3 cm), and Q4 (>2.3 cm).

Close

Figure 5:

Receiver operator characteristic (ROC) curve of ultrasound-guided fine-needle aspiration cytology (US-FNAC) in diagnosing pathological natures of thyroid nodules with different diameters. (a-d) Shows the ROC curve of US-FNAC in the diagnosis of groups Q1, Q2, Q3 , and Q4. 93 patients were divided into groups Q1 (≤1.6 cm), Q2 (1.7–1.9 cm), Q3 (2.0–2.3 cm), and Q4 (>2.3 cm).

Export to PPT

DISCUSSION

Fine-needle aspiration cytology and ultrasonic examination are key tools for pre-operative evaluation of patients with thyroid lesions.^[18-20] Ultrasound examination provides a reference for nodular selection in US-FNAC. Ultrasound guidance assists physicians in seeking a more accurate puncture path and the best puncture position, thus effectively avoiding blood vessels and nerves and improving the success rate of puncture while ensuring safety. In comparison with palpation-guided fine-needle aspiration cytology, USFNAC has higher accuracy.^[21] A foreign study indicated that ultrasound features such as low echo, fine calcification, irregular edge, and nodular aspect ratio >1 were potential indicators of malignant thyroid nodules.^[22] This is consistent with the result of the analysis of this study, which fully confirms the application value of ultrasonic examination in fine-needle aspiration cytology of thyroid nodules.

The US-FNAC results in this study showed 9 (9.18%) benign nodules, 84 (85.72%) malignant nodules, and 5 (5.10%) nodules with uncertain pathological natures 2 (2.04%) specimens had unsatisfactory diagnoses, and 3 (3.06%) specimens were atypical cellular lesions with unclear diagnostic significance). According to surgical pathology results, two benign nodules and one malignant nodule were not correctly diagnosed in this study, including that two nodules were diagnosed as Hashimoto’s thyroiditis by pre-operative US-FNAC but were diagnosed as papillary carcinoma by surgery. Hou et al.^[23] have also obtained similar results, finding that Hashimoto’s thyroiditis, a risk factor for the increase of false-negative rate, would reduce the diagnostic accuracy of US-FNAC. There may be two main reasons for this phenomenon, uniform lesions can result in omission during the puncture process, and second, insufficient experience among physicians can lead to incorrect cytopathologic diagnoses. In addition, one nodule was diagnosed with a malignant tumor by pre-operative USFNAC but was diagnosed as Hashimoto’s thyroiditis by surgical pathology, speculating that it may be related to the limitations of US-FNAC. US-FNAC is based on ultrasonic features, but some benign nodules are easily misdiagnosed as malignant tumors because of irregular edges and uneven echoes.

It has been reported that the accuracy of US-FNAC may also be affected by the size of thyroid nodules.^[24,25] In response to this problem, this study divided the patients into four groups according to the median and quartile. Statistical analysis found the AUCs of groups Q1, Q2, Q3, and Q4>0.9, and USFNAC had high diagnostic efficiency for the pathological properties of thyroid nodules with different diameters. We speculate that this may be related to the small number of cases in our study. The needle may slide out of the nodule during sampling or enter the normal tissue. In addition, Zhao et al.^[26] point out that nodular size has a certain effect on the positive rate of fine needle aspiration, mainly due to the lower diagnostic efficiency of conventional ultrasound on suspected malignant features in small nodules. Therefore, it is necessary to actively perform long-term follow-up for patients with thyroid nodules in types I and III through US-FNAC and patients with small nodular diameters and perform repeat punctures if necessary.

However, US-FNAC diagnosis is also susceptible to factors such as clinical physicians’ diagnostic experience and proficiency.^[27-29] In this study, two patients were excluded due to inexperienced physicians who caused puncture failure, with an incidence of 1.90% (2/105) when screening patients, and this situation needs attention, although the incidence is not high. It is advocated that experienced physicians should perform US-FNAC, and patients should experience comprehensive evaluation before puncture to minimize the occurrence of adverse conditions such as insufficient sample acquisition, diluted blood cells caused by bleeding at the puncture site, and failure of puncture to reach the lesion site, thereby improving the effectiveness, accuracy, and safety of US-FNAC.

There are some limitations in this study. First, among patients undergoing US-FNAC, most patients with malignant nodules and few patients with benign nodules will receive surgical treatment, so selection bias occurred. Second, this single-center study had small sample numbers, so subsequent studies need to extend the observation time and increase the samples. Finally, the different studies had multiple grouping criteria for nodular size, affecting the study results. Therefore, complete verification should be taken by including more samples and conducting multiple studies to provide more reliable information for clinical work.

SUMMARY

US-FNAC has a high diagnostic efficiency for the pathological properties of thyroid nodules. Whether the nodule diameter has an effect on the accuracy of this method requires more clinical evidence.

AVAILABILITY OF DATA AND MATERIALS

The data that support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.

ABBREVIATIONS

US-FNAC- ultrasound-guided fine-needle aspiration cytology ROC- receiver operator characteristic ATA- American Thyroid Association

AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS

GX: Interpreted the data and wrote the manuscript; WT: Designed the study; WT and GX: Contributed to writing the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final version of the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript. All authors have participated sufficiently in the work and agreed to be accountable for all aspects of the work.