Use of grape-based stain (Vinatela) on cervical cytology: A Peruvian validation study

INTRODUCTION

To show the cellular and tissue components, staining techniques are required that allow the differentiation of intrinsic structures, which are not detectable to the human eye. Since cellular components (such as mitochondria and nuclear histones) have different characteristics toward the use of different dyes, due to qualitative or quantitative affinities according to electrical charge, different types of dyes are used (with different auxochromic groups and mordants) for certain cellular structures.^[1] If the success of the staining depends on these characteristics, then the purpose of the staining is to facilitate the visualization of different structures and to demonstrate their chemical and physical differences between the cellular components.

The Papanicolaou (Pap) stain is a polychromic stain, widely used for the diagnosis of precancerous and cancerous lesions, the estimation of hormonal status, and the status of infections.^[2,3] Pap stain is economical, efficient, and fast staining, which has allowed the detection of cervical cancer in high-income countries, dramatically decreasing their mortality rates, and currently constitutes the key piece of secondary prevention of cervical cancer programs worldwide.^[4-6] Unfortunately, the current state of many health centers implies few resources to purchase dyes, chemical reagents, glassware, and other supplies in a timely manner.^[7] All this add to the toxicity of several of the conventional reagents used during staining. This highlights need to search for faster, simpler, low-cost, and less toxic alternatives for the diagnosis of cervical cancer through exfoliative cytology.^[8-10]

From the 1950s to the present day, modifications of the conventional Pap staining have been developed in its different components, stages, and staining time.^[8,11,12] Hematoxylin, a nuclear dye, has undergone substantial modifications on its same chemical basis, preventing the use of other plant derivatives for this purpose.^[10-13]

The validation of new dyes from other natural sources showing high performance by staining cell nuclei and cytoplasmic components without errors, constitutes a challenge for natural product-research in low-income countries where they require innovation activities for the benefit of Public Health and Global Environmental Health.

We aimed to validate the use of the dye extracted from the grapes (Vinatela) cultivated in the South of Peru, as a staining agent in normal cervical samples.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Samples of grapes

The present validation study was conducted with two grape species (Vitis vinifera “Tempranillo” and V. v. “Malbec”). These samples were collected from two vineyards belonging to the Agroindustrial Research Institute of the San Juan Bautista Private University (UPSJB), located in the South of Peru – Ica Region [Figure 1]. All the samples were collected aseptically by breaking. Grapes with visible damage, rotten or obviously contaminated, were excluded from the study. These were transported to the Research Laboratories of the UPSJB Headquarters in Lima, for the extraction of the dyeing compounds after characterization. This study was approved by the Ethics Committee of the UPSJB (No. 016-2018-VRIUPSJB.

Close

Figure 1:

Location of the harvesting areas of the Vitis vinifera “Tempranillo” and “Malbec” grape varieties in Ica, Peru. Fundo 368 (purple star) and Fundo Normita (green star).

Export to PPT

Extraction of dye compounds

The extraction of the dyeing compounds from the two grape varieties was carried out in three stages: (1) direct cell coloration tests with pre-fermentation wine products (must) that were obtained from the ARPE winery of the UPSJB, (2) the extraction method by direct fragmentation of grapes, where the shells of the grape species were used directly on the smear,^[14] and (3) alcoholic extraction of the dye following the protocol of Hernández (2017).^[15] The protocols are detailed in [Figure 2].

Close

Figure 2:

Staining test with Vinatela dye extracted from grape species from Ica, Peru on cervical samples. (a) Protocol 1, direct coloring with pre-fermented wine (must). (b) Protocol 2, coloration test with pH change in pre-fermented wines (must). (c) Hydroalcoholic extraction of “Vinatela” dye.

Export to PPT

For all the extraction products, the physical and chemical characteristics (pH and concentration of wine staining compounds) were evaluated and their nuclear cell affinity capacity (basophilic) was evaluated by microscopy and macroscopy according to previous protocol.^[16]

RESULTS

The first staining protocol included direct staining and modification of the pre-fermented wine (must), demonstrating a range of effectiveness [Figure 3]. Of the two grape species used in this protocol, the V. v. Malbec species showed better performance and stained numerous basophilic structures observed during the macroscopic controls. The use of potassium alum (20 g), hydrogen peroxide (100 µL), and incubation (at 35 ± 2°C) improved the performance in each stage and for both species (V. v. Malbec and V. v. Tempranillo). After identifying the direct dyeing performance of both grape species, the pH of the solution was changed, showing that the alkalinity of the species improved the affinity of the anthocyanin dyes toward the cellular structures (mainly tests 5 and 7) [Figure 2].

Close

Figure 3:

Baseline characteristics of the study. (a) Sample collection sites, UPSJB vineyards, Ica, Peru. (b) Grape species included in the study (V. v. Tempranillo -top - and V. v. Malbec - below).(c) V. v. Tempranillo and Malbec grape shells. (d) Evaluation of dyeing capacity on filter paper. (e) Extraction of grape dye under Protocol 3. (f) Comparison of dyeing capacity of grape species by drag. V. v.: Vitis vinifera.

Export to PPT

From these tests, we proceeded to extract the peel of both grape varieties, for subsequent analysis and testing of dyeing capacity. In [Table 1], the amounts in grams of grape peel obtained by each species are detailed. On average, 200 g of peel were extracted in 2 kg of grapes. With these shells, the staining capabilities by direct rubbing were compared [Figure 3], showing the greater capacity of the V. v. Malbec species. After this test, the dye was extracted, obtaining 4 ± 0.5 mL per grape species (Vinatela solution). With this alcoholic dye, the cervical cytology samples were stained for 20 min, improving the staining capacity [Table 1].

Our results showed differences between direct staining and the Vinatela protocol, the latter being the one that showed the best affinity and dyeing capacity. [Figure 4] shows the control of nuclear staining with each protocol in cervical smears stained with Vinatela. Then, cellular staining characteristics were observed in the nuclear details of both epithelial and polymorphonuclear cells in normal/benign smears [Figure 5]. The mean of the staining procedure was 12 min.

Close

Figure 4:

Photomicrographs of cervical smears stained under the three staining protocols. With protocol 1 (a-d), no staining of the cellular components was obtained with V. v. Tempranillo (a and b), with V. v. Malbec slightly higher staining results were obtained (c and d). With protocol 2, improvements in staining capacity were obtained mainly in the 5:5 dilution (e and f) with V. v. Malbec. Protocol 3 (Vinatela) showed better cervical cell staining capacity (g-i), the staining capacity was slightly higher with V. v. Malbec (h and i). V. v.: Vitis vinifera.

Export to PPT

Close

Figure 5:

Photomicrographs of cervical smears stained with Vinatela-based-V. v. Malbec. (a) Negative for intraepithelial lesion or malignancy (NILM), intermediate squamous cells with surrounding peripheral erythrocytes. (b) NILM, navicular cells. (c) NILM, metaplastic squamous cells. (d) NILM, shift in flora suggestive of bacterial vaginosis. V. v.: Vitis vinifera.

Export to PPT

We found better staining characteristics between V. v. Malbec versus V. v. Tempranillo (P = 0.045). The SQI assessment of staining established an overall SQI of 0.89 (ideal 1). Basophilic component scores showed SQI = 0.90 for chromatic pattern and nuclear staining, SQI = 0.95 for membrane continuity, SQI = 0.80 for background, and SQI = 0.89 for staining overview.

DISCUSSION

This study demonstrated the ability to stain basophilic cellular components with the grape-based stain “Vinatela” on cervical samples from Peruvian women. Of the two evaluated species, our results showed a better performance of V. v. Malbec, evidenced in the cellular characteristics evaluated macroscopically and microscopically.

The strengths of this study are supported by the extraction of a stock solution of grape dye (Vinatela) under an alcoholic extraction protocol.^[15] As previously described, there is interest in the textile industry in obtaining and using natural colorants extracted from native species of grapes, corn (Zea mays), etc.^[19-23] The dyes extracted from these species represent a great economic contribution to the industry of different countries, producing an annual investment of 500 million dollars in Latin America.^[14] In this sense, our findings contribute to the research in the extraction of natural dyes and exceed this previous purpose using it as a cell stain of basophilic structures. Thus, it could be used in routine clinical and pathological laboratory stains (Pap stain, basophilic stain in the carbolfuchsin technique for the determination of sex chromatin, wright for blood smears, Gram for bacteria staining, etc.). This topic requires future application research.

The limitations of this study are mainly due to the nature of its design. This is the first study with an exploratory approach that has focused its methodological development on first achieving the extraction of the grape stain, and second, demonstrating its affinity toward the basophilic components of the cervical cellular structures being able to estimate their staining quality in the macro and microscopic evaluation.

In this sense, the Vinatela stain obtained from V. v. Malbec demonstrated an optimal global SQI (0.89), being comparable with the prolonged Pap modification (SQI = 0.94), with the ultrafast Pap staining (quality index = very good), with the Cytocolor (Szczepanik modification) (SQI = 0.87), with the short Pap’s eosin-thiazine stain, and with the ecological stain of Pap (Eco-Pap) (SQI = 0.94). ^{[9,10,16,18,24,25]}

On the other hand, the development of natural colorants that can be used in pathology laboratories is part of the Sustainable Development Goals (SDG) of the United Nations for 2030.^[26] Efforts for laboratories to reduce their high proportion of daily pollutants are one of the commitments that laboratories and environmental health control organizations must prioritize since tons of toxic pollutants with high carcinogenic potential are eliminated daily causing a carbon footprint^[27] and play an irreplaceable role as submarine emissaries (destroying the marine life that irreparably worsens the depressed state of the current climate).

As we proposed with the creation of the Eco-Pap,^[10] the development of laboratories specialized in natural colorants is required, which through technology transfer could reduce the impact of environmental pollution and boost the bioeconomy of the countries of the region. This progress in the study of natural dyes cannot only address the SDGs (meeting 6 of the 17 objectives), but through its development, it contributes to improving Global Environmental Health and being able to be incorporated into the routine flow work of laboratory (mainly in the Pap, which is used as the main mass secondary prevention tool) could improve cervical cancer screening (which has increased in the past 6 years)^[28] contributing to Public Health.

Vinatela initiates a new scope of action for components derived from grapes. The textile and wine industry already generates an income, being able to benefit from the possible use of grape-based stains within pathology laboratories. In this study, native grapes were used and grown in the UPSJB vineyards, highlighting the grape species from southern Peru.

SUMMARY

We validated the Vinatela nuclear stain, from grapes grown in Peru through the alcoholic-extraction protocol, in normal cervical samples as Pap test with optimal staining quality.